Comment

The Real Estate Board of New York to The Landmarks Preservation Commission on Proposed Amendments to LPC Rules

Kate Goldmann

Senior Housing and Planning Analyst

•

November 16, 2026

Share This

The Real Estate Board of New York (REBNY) is the City’s leading real estate trade association representing commercial, residential, industrial, and institutional property owners, builders, managers, investors, brokers, salespeople, and other organizations and individuals active in New York City real estate. REBNY appreciates the opportunity to comment on the Landmarks Preservation Commission's (LPC) proposed amendments to its rules governing work on designated landmark properties.

REBNY support the Commission's efforts to modernize its regulatory framework, improve transparency and predictability, and expand the range of projects that can be reviewed and approved at the staff level while continuing to protect the City's historic resources. The proposed amendments represent a meaningful step toward making the landmark approval process more efficient and responsive to the needs of property owners and the communities in which they operate. By expanding staff-level approval pathways for a range of work, including office-to-residential conversions, ancillary dwelling units, window and opening modifications, rear additions, rooftop improvements, and accessibility upgrades, the rules recognize that historic buildings must be able to adapt to contemporary needs.

Importantly, expanding staff-level approvals will reduce the time and expense associated with projects that would otherwise require Commission-level review, referral to the local community board, and a public hearing. In many instances, the proposed amendments codify approval practices that have become routine at the Commission level but are not currently eligible for staff-level review. Establishing clear standards for these types of work will provide greater certainty for property owners and applicants, streamline the review process, and allow the Commission to focus its resources on projects that warrant more extensive review.

The proposed changes permitting greater use of substitute materials are particularly valuable. For example, allowing substitute materials for terra cotta will reduce the time and expense associated with fabricating custom units, helping facilitate repairs and the faster removal of sidewalk sheds. Similarly, greater flexibility to use substitute materials on garages and secondary structures will encourage necessary repair and restoration work where the requirement to use historic materials or obtain Commission-level approval might otherwise discourage owner investment. Additional allowances for substitute materials on roofs and windows will reduce burdens on residential property owners and make it easier to maintain and improve existing housing. The proposed changes regarding skylights and dormers, as well as the new standards governing rear-yard and rooftop additions, will further support the modernization and improvement of residential buildings while facilitating more efficient staff-level approvals and reducing uncertainty for applicants.

REBNY also encourages the Commission to consider further liberalizing restrictions on alterations to windows on the top floors of rowhouses, townhouses, and flats where those windows are not visible from a public way. Where lower-floor windows have been modified to meet modern standards for light and functionality, there is limited public benefit in retaining smaller, outdated windows on an upper floor that cannot be seen from the street. Greater flexibility in these circumstances would allow owners to make more consistent functional improvements to their properties without compromising the public visibility or historic character of the building.

Additionally, the removal of enhanced engineering review from the general design review process is a sensible change. To the extent enhanced engineering review is necessary, conducting that review as part of the staff-level review of excavation and other foundation work is a more logical and efficient approach that can improve coordination and reduce duplicative review.

These objectives are particularly important as New York City works to address its housing challenges and advance the goals of City of Yes for Housing Opportunity. City of Yes recognizes that meeting the City's housing goals requires making better use of existing buildings and creating opportunities for additional housing across neighborhoods. Landmark properties are an important part of the City's building stock, and the ability to appropriately modernize and rehabilitate these properties is essential. Zoning reforms and other efforts to encourage housing production are most effective when the related regulatory and permitting processes are clear, coordinated, and predictable.

Thank you for the opportunity to provide comments, and we look forward to further engagement on this topic.

CONTACT:

Kate Goldmann

Senior Housing and Planning Analyst

Real Estate Board of New York

kgoldmann@rebny.com