Comment

The Real Estate Board of New York to The Department of City Planning on Proposed Rules Governing the Assignment and Verification of Street Numbers

Maddie DeCerbo

Senior Director of Urban Planning

•

November 16, 2026

Share This

The Real Estate Board of New York (REBNY) is the City’s leading real estate trade association representing commercial, residential, and institutional property owners, builders, managers, investors, brokers, salespeople, and other organizations and individuals active in New York City real estate. REBNY appreciates the opportunity to submit comments on the Department of City Planning’s (DCP) proposed rules governing the assignment and verification of street numbers.

REBNY supported the 2025 Charter amendments approved by voters through Ballot Question 5, which modernized the City Map and centralized the administration of street addresses. We support the City's efforts to establish a more consistent and streamlined framework for assigning and verifying street numbers, which can provide greater clarity for property owners, applicants, and City agencies.

As DCP undertakes this new responsibility, it is important that the implementing rules establish a clear, predictable, and efficient process while minimizing unnecessary costs and administrative burdens for property owners. We offer the following comments for the Department's consideration.

REBNY is concerned about the proposed standardized fee schedule, which will replace existing borough-specific fee structures with a uniform citywide schedule. Under proposed 62 RCNY §§ 3-12 and 3-13, applications would be subject to nonreturnable fees, including a $245 fee for street number verification, an initial $340 and final $195 fee for street number assignments, and a $4,910 fee for vanity address assignments. While the proposed fees may represent a reduction for certain applicants, they may also result in significant increases for others, depending on the borough and type of application. The proposal does not sufficiently explain the methodology used to establish these charges nor demonstrate how they relate to the Department's actual cost of processing applications. DCP should provide a comparison of the existing borough-specific fees and proposed citywide fees, along with the cost basis for each charge, to demonstrate that the proposed schedule is intended to recover administrative costs rather than generate additional revenue given both the routine and critical necessity of address assignment.

REBNY is also concerned about the provision in proposed § 3-12 that imposes an additional fee for any subsequent application filed in relation to a pending application. Combined with the nonreturnable nature of the initial application fees, this provision could unnecessarily increase costs for property owners making routine design modifications or responding to requests for additional information during the review process. The Department should clarify what constitutes a subsequent application and distinguish between a new application and revisions, supplemental materials, or modifications to an existing filing. REBNY recommends allowing applicants to amend pending applications without incurring an additional application fee where the underlying request remains substantially the same. The Department should also consider providing credits or refunds for withdrawn applications, particularly where substantive review has not yet occurred.

With respect to street number display and signage, proposed § 16-05 establishes specific requirements for the size, form, visibility, and placement of street numbers, including a minimum height of five inches and a minimum stroke width of one-half inch. The proposal also authorizes the Director to require additional exterior and interior directional signage where street numbers may not be clearly visible or may not adequately direct the public to a particular location within a building. While REBNY recognizes the importance of clear and consistent street identification for public safety and emergency response, these requirements should be implemented in a manner that avoids unnecessary modifications to existing properties. The Department's Statement of Basis and Purpose indicates that the proposed specifications are intended to be consistent with existing Building, Fire, and Housing Maintenance Code requirements. Accordingly, REBNY recommends that existing street number and address signage that complies with applicable Building and Fire Code requirements be considered compliant and not require replacement or modification solely as a result of the new rules. The Department should also establish clear criteria for when additional directional signage will be required, particularly given the Director's discretion under § 16-05(e) to require signage based on building configuration, setbacks, entrances, and internal circulation. Clear standards will provide property owners with greater predictability and help avoid duplicative or unnecessary signage requirements. This would also reduce rework or revised application submissions that would trigger the additional cost burden outlined above.

Finally, REBNY encourages the Department to provide clarity regarding the implementation and enforcement of these requirements for existing buildings. Proposed § 16-07 identifies the respective enforcement responsibilities of the Department of Buildings, the Department of Housing Preservation and Development, and the Fire Department, and provides for civil penalties for noncompliance. Given the potential for violations arising from signage and street number requirements, the Department should clarify how the new standards will apply to existing buildings to ensure that property owners have reasonable notice and an opportunity to address any identified deficiencies before penalties are imposed.

REBNY appreciates the Department's consideration of these comments and looks forward to working with DCP to ensure that the implementation of this new framework advances the City's objectives while providing a transparent, predictable, and efficient process for property owners.

CONTACTS:
Maddie DeCerbo
Senior Director of Urban Planning
Real Estate Board of New York
Mdecerbo@rebny.com